The ManyPets run · 2020–2022
I joined ManyPets as its first U.S. hire. Two years later, it was a $2 billion company.
I led global growth and the U.S. launch. Premium went from $33M to $280M, and the company from $60M to a $2B valuation.
But the interesting part isn’t that it grew. It’s that most of the growth was already there, trapped inside a confusing name, an under-monetized product, rented distribution, a U.S. market nobody had cracked, and a retention engine that was never built to compound.
This is the system we built to let it out. No theory, no vanity metrics. Just the levers, in the order we pulled them.
8×
revenue growth, in two years
33×
increase in company valuation
#1
fastest-growing pet brand in the U.S.
The rebrand · Bought By Many becomes ManyPets
The mandate
Take a sleepy UK insurer global. Win the hardest market in the category. Don’t break the economics doing it.
When I joined, ManyPets was still “Bought By Many,” about 85,000 pets, $33M in premium, basically all in the UK. The mandate: build a global brand, crack the U.S. (the toughest market in pet insurance), and do it without torching unit economics. As employee #1 in the States, I owned that market from zero, then built the team that ran it.
One belief ran through everything: insurance is a trust-and-LTV game. You don’t win it by outspending everyone on ads. You win by making the brand easier to trust, building loops that compound, and keeping people for years.
The system
Six levers, in the order we pulled them.
Each one tied to economics. Not a vanity metric in sight.
01
First, the name had to go. CAC fell everywhere.
“Bought By Many” was a mouthful nobody trusted on sight, and a weak brand taxes every conversion downstream. So we fixed it first. I led the global rebrand end to end: name, identity, messaging, positioning. Not a design project. A CAC-reduction lever that made everything beneath it cheaper.
+150% brand awareness · +300 bps retention
02
Then the product started doing the selling.
We refactored the global product taxonomy and built a system of growth loops, so acquisition compounded through the product itself, not just paid spend. One of the biggest engines behind the run to $280M.
+250% policies, year over year
03
A $25M engine that spoke one language: LTV:CAC.
Paid, SEO, lifecycle: all on a rapid-experimentation framework the team ran across product, marketing, and engineering. Every test had to ladder to LTV:CAC or it got killed. We built technical and content SEO from scratch to a 38 authority score in a year.
4:1 blended LTV:CAC · 38 domain authority
04
Then we stopped renting customers and started owning distribution.
We sourced, negotiated, and shipped 18 partnerships that became the majority of U.S. volume. Paid media gets you off the ground; partnerships give you lower-CAC distribution that compounds. This is the lever that made the U.S. math actually work.
18 deals · 60% of U.S. sales volume
05
We launched the U.S. with three people and a spreadsheet.
End to end (product, pricing, and GTM) into 40 states (85% of TAM) in twelve months. The part PE people love: a three-person team, zero outsourcing, $7M in premium in year one. Effective, and a little absurd how efficient.
40 states · 85% of TAM · 15K customers · $7M GWP
06
And then we made sure they actually stayed.
Acquisition is only half of LTV:CAC. We worked with Product, Claims, and Customer Service to build a journey people don’t churn out of. In insurance, retention is the whole game. It’s where the LTV that funds all that acquisition comes from.
NPS 78 · 98.75% monthly gross retention
The result
Two hockey sticks. We built both.
One chart is the global business scaling. The other is the U.S. launching from zero. Two different scales, one playbook.
85K → 550K
pets insured
$33M → $280M
in premium, over two years
$60M → $2B
company valuation
Fix the core business.
Prove the playbook travels.
Why it transfers
None of it was luck, or one magic channel. It was a system. And it’s the same one we run now.
Make the brand easier to trust. Compound it with product. Own the distribution. Defend the LTV. Marketing, sales, and product run as one, reported in EBITDA, not vanity metrics. It’s exactly what we now do for PE-backed companies at Day One Growth.
Bring this to your portfolio →